BP vs. CertainTeed: Which Shingles Brand to Choose?

BP vs. CertainTeed: Which Shingles Brand to Choose?

Handyman's World is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.

If you are looking for a good roofing and shingles manufacturer to choose from, then there are plenty of brands to consider. This is exactly what makes deciding on a specific one so difficult, as the selection is so massive. However, there are some brands that are more popular than others, with BP and CertainTeed being two of them.

Today, we want to do a side-by-side comparison of the two to see which of these two roof shingles brands is better for you.

BP Overview

BP ShinglesStarting off, we have BP, which is known as Building Products of Canada, hence a Canadian brand name. This is a brand that has been producing high-quality or even premium shingles since 1905, therefore making it a very old company.

It was actually first founded in the 1700s but did not start making roofing shingles until 1905. This is a privately owned company based in Quebec and it has four manufacturing facilities throughout Canada.

What many people like about BP as a company is that one of its main focuses is creating shingles that are designed to handle cold Canadian climates.

Consumers also appreciate how BP produces fairly high-quality products that come in at decent prices.

They aren’t the cheapest shingles in the world, but also not the most expensive. One of the most popular shingles from this brand name is the Vanguard, so this is what we will be focusing on today.

CertainTeed Overview

CertainTeedWe then have CertainTeed, which is at this time one of the largest roofing and shingles manufacturers in the USA and Canada, as well as one of the oldest. Interestingly enough, it has been around since 1904, and they currently have over 60 different retail and manufacturing facilities in the USA and Canada.

It’s also known as one of the biggest asphalt shingle brands in the United States. One of the defining features of this brand is that the product selection is absolutely massive.

Furthermore, many people like CertainTeed because all of their shingles are designed to be extremely large and heavy, much heavier than other brands, and they also contain more asphalt than other competitors.

This means that they weigh up to 50% more than the shingles from other brands, making them super impact-resistant, and wind-resistant, as well as giving them great protection from granule loss, and more.

These are some of the most popular and sought-after shingles in the world, with the Landmark shingle being one of the most popular of all.

It is also one of the more expensive shingles from this brand, although CertainTeed does also have some more affordable options if that’s what you’re looking for.

BP vs. CertainTeed: How Do They Compare?

Now that we know a little bit about both of these brand names, let’s take a look at how they compare on a side-by-side basis.

Product Lineup

What stands out about CertainTeed as a brand is that there are no fewer than 14 different types of shingles to choose from, with the Landmark shingle being one of the most popular.

BP, on the other hand, only has about five different types of asphalt shingles to choose from. As you can see, the product selection from CertainTeed is about three times as large as its Canadian competitor.

Overall Quality

Most people would say that BP has absolutely excellent shingles, and would rank them as being either high-quality or even premier.

BP shingles are regarded as being in a higher echelon as far as shingles are concerned, although they aren’t the very best in the world. Most people would rate them at somewhere around a four out of five in terms of overall quality.

On the other hand, if we are talking about CertainTeed, these are viewed as being some of the very best shingles in the world, and it’s all due to their weight. These are known for being extremely high-quality.


When it comes to durability, BP is no slouch. The shingles from BP are designed to be very durable, with many technologies and manufacturing processes being used to make them very impact-resistant, algae-resistant, and more. BP shingles are of course also designed to handle cold weather very well.

On the other hand, we have those super heavyweight CertainTeed shingles that are made with tons of asphalt. They are heavy, big, wind-resistant, fire-resistant, algae-resistant, impact-resistant, and more. They are simply some of the most durable shingles in the world.

Wind Rating

Virtually all of the shingles from both of these brand names, including the Vanguard and the Landmark, feature wind rantings of 130 mph. On this front, both brands are virtually the same.

Algae Resistance

One of the areas where BP shingles fall short is with algae resistance. Now, they are not particularly prone to developing algae, although they are also not very resistant to it.

Remember that these shingles are designed more for cold and extreme weather than anything else. On the other hand, CertainTeed uses a wide variety of manufacturing processes and substances that help prevent algae from growing on its products.

Energy Efficiency

Both of these brands feature many different shingles that are Energy Star certified and rated as being very energy efficient, and this includes both the Vanguard and the Landmark.

Fire Rating

Both of the shingles being looked at today, as well as most of the shingles from both brands in general, feature Class A fire ratings, which are the very best you can get.


All of the shingles from both of these brand names, except for a few exceptions, come with limited lifetime warranties, although those from CertainTeed seem to be a bit more comprehensive.


You can get BP shingles for anywhere between $1.70 and $4 per square foot, whereas CertainTeed shingles will start at $4 per square foot, and go all the way up to $8.50 per square foot.

BP vs. CertainTeed: Which Offers Better Roofing Shingles?

The bottom line here is that BP is an excellent brand to go with, especially for cold weather conditions. It produces fairly high-quality products at reasonable prices. However, if you need shingles that will outpace the competitor on every front, and you are willing to pay for them, then CertainTeed is absolutely the best brand to go with.

What it comes down to is that BP is the better budget-friendly brand, whereas CertainTeed is the better brand to consider if you just need really high-quality shingles and you’re willing to pay that higher price.

How Do BP and CertainTeed Compare with Other Shingles Brands?

See how BP compares with: GAF | IKO

See how CertainTeed compares with: AtlasGAF | IKO | Malarkey | Owens Corning | TAMKO